Cruise Ship Control

Disney Cruise Line pulls into the port on the Seattle waterfront this spring. Do these behemoth boat

By Seattle Mag January 12, 2012

0212cruise_0_0

This article originally appeared in the February 2012 issue of Seattle magazine.

They pour into Seattle by the hundreds of thousands: cruise ship passengers from all over the world, clamoring to board floating cities for slo-mo luxury tours of Puget Sound and points beyond. Seattle has become a major launching spot for cruise ships setting sail to southeast Alaska, with its cavorting whales, calving glaciers and staggeringly beautiful snowy-mountain vistas. Alaska is such a popular destination nowadays that Disney Cruise Line is getting into the game; beginning this spring, Disney will join other major lines—Holland America, Norwegian, Carnival, Celebrity, Princess and Royal Caribbean—to dock their behemoth waterborne hotels in Seattle.

So what does that mean for the already pressured, ecologically significant waterways of Puget Sound, the nation’s second-largest estuary (behind Chesapeake Bay)? According to the state agency Puget Sound Partnership, the body of water is already hard hit on numerous fronts with contaminated runoff from streets and industry; failing septic systems; and an increase of housing developments covering hillsides that were once forested land. The group estimates that billions of dollars are needed to clean up the Sound and restore it to better health. But, like those of most government programs, funds for the project are being cut; the Puget Sound Partnership will have to shave off 10 percent of its budget for 2012.

That could make it a pretty big deal for yet another cruise line to begin operating here. Cruise ships are basically floating cities, complete with a city’s big-time concerns, such as sewage, trash and air pollution. A typical one-week voyage can produce hundreds of thousands of gallons of sewage; millions of gallons of gray water from sinks, kitchens and laundry facilities; and tons of trash, according to the national environmental advocacy group Friends of the Earth, which tracks the cruise ship industry. The ships also kick out pollutants like sulfur dioxide and nitrogen from their enormous engines.

“The dirtiest fuel on the planet is burned on cruise ships: bunker fuel,” says Marcie Keever, oceans and vessels project director for Friends of the Earth. “Bunker fuel is thousands of times dirtier than on-road diesel truck fuel. It’s so heavy, it’s in almost a semi-solid state.”

Sounds bad, but those who monitor the health of Puget Sound say it might not be too bad, if—and it’s a big if—Disney and all of the other cruise lines continue to make running clean a priority. Both increasing regulations and voluntary efforts by the cruise lines are improving the environmental picture, Keever says. The Port of Seattle has installed a shore power infrastructure at Pier 91 that allows cruise ships to plug in at the docks, rather than run their engines. “The power supplied by ports on the West Coast is considerably cleaner [than running engines], with air pollution benefits,” Keever says.

That’s good news to Kimberley Cline, spokeswoman for the Puget Sound Clean Air Agency. “We are definitely pleased to hear the Disney ships will use shore power when berthed,” she says.

But Congressman Jim McDermott (D-Seattle), who has pushed for tougher environmental regulations regarding cruise ships, sounds unconvinced. “These ships release thousands of gallons of sewage, garbage and wastewater into our waters,” he says. “Before these lines start running, I would like to see Disney—and other operators—commit to ensuring a clean operation that will ensure the long-term health of the Sound and coastal waters.”

The cruise lines all say they have done just that, adhering to federal regulations that require the ships to discharge their dirty water outside of Puget Sound, in open ocean, a minimum of three miles from shore. When in international waters—cruising past Canada, for instance—ships must be at least 12 miles out to sea. And Disney says it goes a lot further, citing voluntary efforts focused on “utilizing new technologies, increasing fuel efficiency, minimizing waste and supporting conservation worldwide.” “We have dedicated environmental officers aboard each Disney ship [who are] responsible for all recycling, waste minimization and environmental compliance,” says Bert Swets, vice president of marine and technical operations for Disney. “We were also the first in the industry to apply a special eco-friendly hull coating to our ships.”

According to Friends of the Earth, Disney is doing a better job these days of addressing environmental concerns, earning a “most improved” rating on the group’s annual cruise line scorecard. “They retrofitted both their ships to install advanced wastewater treatment,” Keever says. “Disney is doing the right thing, and they’re going in the right direction.”

Another thing going in the right direction: Seattle’s bottom line. Those big ships mean big money, and it’s money Seattle really needs. The Port of Seattle reports that each ship steaming out of Seattle to Alaska leaves about $1.9 million in its wake, with its hundreds of passengers shopping, eating and staying at local hotels. In addition, in 2011, the cruise industry brought in $18.9 million in state and local taxes, and 4,447 jobs, according to the Port, and those numbers are expected to go up this year with Disney on board. The Port projects that a whopping 880,918 cruise passengers will take 201 scheduled cruise ship trips out of the city in 2012, from two ports (one downtown, at Pier 66, and one in Magnolia, at Pier 91). This hopping cruise industry is “a critical component” of Seattle’s tourism industry, according to Seattle’s Convention and Visitors Bureau, and it appears on track to keep growing. According to the Cruise Lines International Association, an industry group that represents nearly all the major lines, Alaska is the second-most-popular destination (after the Caribbean) for cruisers.

Beginning on May 28, the Disney Wonder—a 964-foot-long, 83,000-ton temporary home to 2,700 travelers—will launch a total of 14 seven-night cruises from Seattle, steaming north to the scenic Tracy Arm fjord and the towns of Skagway, Juneau and Ketchikan, as well as Victoria, British Columbia.

Which could actually be an environmental plus, according to Tom Bancroft, executive director of the environmental advocacy group People for Puget Sound. “Disney has a great opportunity to raise the bar for the cruise industry here,” he says. “They’ve got an opportunity to provide environmental educational opportunities while on Puget Sound. I think the chance for people all over the country to get that perspective while on a cruise is just fantastic. We want to see people from all over country come and say, ‘This should be protected.’”

 

Follow Us

Bumbershoot Eyes Former Bed Bath & Beyond Space 

Bumbershoot Eyes Former Bed Bath & Beyond Space 

Bumbershoot and Muckleshoot Tribe plan music, arts venue

Bumbershoot producer New Rising Sun has partnered with the Muckleshoot Indian Tribe to convert the vacant 66,000-square-foot space for an opening by spring 2025.

Molbak’s Returns

Molbak’s Returns

Popular store launches community hub for gardening

Molbak’s has launched a new community initiative called Green Phoenix Collaborative at Molbak’s, which will transform the former retail site into a community hub for all things gardening. The collaborative will feature programs, classes, and events.

Historic Cornish College Building For Sale

Historic Cornish College Building For Sale

Kerry Hall was the original home of college founder Nellie Cornish

The historic Kerry Hall building, at 710 E. Roy St. in Seattle’s Capitol Hill neighborhood, was built in 1921 and was the home of Nellie Cornish, who founded the arts college in 1914 and ran it for 25 years. The college was formed in the building and has occupied it since then.

Seattle: Again The Place To Be

Seattle: Again The Place To Be

Seattle nears pre-pandemic visitor levels in impressive turnaround

Visit Seattle released preliminary figures for 2023 at its annual meeting Wednesday, and found that the region hosted 37.8 million visitors last year, an 8.9% increase from 2022. That’s just 10% less than in 2019, the last full year before the pandemic.