Food & Drink

Find your Perfect Throwback Cocktail

These 10 drinks may not be top of mind, but all pack a punch as well as some colorful history

By Rob Smith December 8, 2020

1120_SEM_067

This article originally appeared in the November/December 2020 issue of Seattle magazine.

Many are saying once the pandemic fades, we’ll experience a Roaring ’20s decade similar to 100 years ago. So, with some downtime to prepare, why not start perfecting your cocktail game now? These 10 concoctions come from a vintage bar guide from Glenn Shaw Creations — supposedly from the 1950s — found in an antique shop in Olympia a few years back. Keep in mind that these drinks may have evolved some since this bar guide’s introduction.

Alexander’s Sister
This cocktail dates back a century and, as its name implies, is related to the classic Brandy Alexander. This one, though, uses gin — and more of it — instead of brandy.

1/2 dry gin, 1/4 crème de menthe, 1/4 cream. Shake well and strain into glass.

Alfonso Cocktail
This one, too, dates back nearly a century and is named after Alfonso XIII, who, as King of Spain, fled the country in 1931 after supporting a failed dictator. Not exactly a proud legacy, but hey, it netted him an alcoholic beverage.

1 lump sugar in a champagne glass, dash with bitters, add ice cube, 1/2 jigger Dubonnet, fill with champagne and add lemon twist.

Betsy Ross

We all learned about her — the person, not the cocktail — in grade school. As the now debunked story goes, George Washington asked Betsy Ross to create the first Ameri-can flag. But just because the story isn’t true doesn’t mean the drink isn’t, uh, strong.

1 jigger brandy, 1 jigger Port, 2 dashes Angostura bitters, 1 dash Curaçao. Stir well with ice and strain into large cocktail glass.

Milk Punch

Emanating from 17th century Britain, this drink still holds up and even appears on some bar menus.

Combine in shaker cracked ice, 2 jiggers of your choice liquor and 1 cup milk. Shake, strain and serve with nutmeg.

Millionaire No. 2

Created during Prohibition, this drink is perhaps best consumed on Be a Millionaire Day, May 18.

1/3 Jamaica rum, apricot brandy and sloe gin, 1 dash grenadine, juice of 1 lime. Shake with ice and strain into a glass.

XYZ

Also known as a rum sidecar, it doesn’t get much simpler, or tastier, than this.

1/2 dark rum, 1/4 Cointreau, 1/4 lemon juice. Shake with crushed ice and strain into glass.

King Alphonse

Recipes now call for Kahlua coffee liqueur.

Fill liqueur glass 3/4 full with dark crème de cacao. Gently float 1/3 heavy cream over a spoon on top.

White Lion

The White Lion dates to at least the 1800s and perhaps earlier. According to website The Zozzled Cocktail, rum in the 1800s was consumed mainly by the poor.

1 jigger rum, juice of half a lemon, 1 teaspoon powdered sugar, 3 dashes each Angostura bitters and raspberry syrup. Shake with ice and strain.

Pisco Punch

Invented in San Francisco in the late 19th century. According to Wikipedia, Pisco is a 16th-century brandy made from grapes of Peru and Chile.

Place 1 piece ice and 1 teaspoon each pineapple and lemon juice into a wine glass. Add 2 jiggers of brandy and a small pineapple cube, and fill with cold water.

Dubonnet Fizz

Dubonnet, a sweet, red French wine, is a bubbly treat.

2 jiggers Dubonnet, 1 teaspoon cherry brandy, 1/2 glass of orange juice and 1/4 lemon juice. Shake with ice and strain. Fill with soda.

Follow Us

Their Spirits Were Not Broken

Their Spirits Were Not Broken

Ballard’s only distillery finally opens after years of setbacks

Covid caused multiple delays in the fabrication of their stills in Germany. A 140-day concrete workers strike created more chaos during build-out, as did city permitting issues. Much of their equipment burned to the ground in a Kent warehouse fire...

Seattle’s Best Fireside Bars 

Seattle’s Best Fireside Bars 

Sip your way through winter at the city’s coziest spots

Seattle is in the heart of its dark, damp, and gloomy stretch — a season that leaves you chilled from the inside out. With plummeting temperatures and near constant drizzle, it can feel challenging to work up the motivation to step outside.

Around the World, Sip by Sip (Part Two)

Around the World, Sip by Sip (Part Two)

Quench your thirst for travel without leaving Seattle

Like wine, mezcal and pisco have been carefully produced in their native countries, Mexico and Peru, for centuries, with each farm, grower, and distiller imparting characteristics that cannot be separated from the land itself. Step into these regions with a glass in hand and conjure the magical streets of Oaxaca or Cusco. Bring the same

Around the World, Sip by Sip (Part One) 

Around the World, Sip by Sip (Part One) 

Quench your thirst for travel without leaving Seattle

Whether it’s a dry rosé that evokes the sense memory of a sunbaked afternoon in Provence, or a crisp pilsner that brings back a boisterous Prague beer hall, libations transport our minds to faraway lands. The next time you go out, bring the same sense of adventure you would to travel by sampling one of…